Obama’s Executive Power Hypocrisy

In the New York Times, Ross Douthat points out that Barack Obama’s main criticisms of George W. Bush had to do with a perceived overreach of executive power:

WHEN George W. Bush was president of the United States, it was an article of faith among liberals that many of his policies were not just misguided but unconstitutional as well. On issues large and small, from the conduct of foreign policy to the firing of United States attorneys, the Bush White House pushed an expansive view of executive authority, and Democrats pushed right back — accusing it of shredding the constitution, claiming near-imperial powers and even corrupting the lawyers working in its service.
That was quite some time ago. Last week the Obama White House invoked executive privilege to shield the Justice Department from a Congressional investigation into a botched gunrunning operation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. The previous week the White House invoked powers that President Obama himself had previously claimed to lack, unilaterally revising the nation’s immigration laws by promising to stop enforcing them against a particularly sympathetic population.
Both moves were entirely characteristic of this presidency. Obama campaigned as a consistent critic of the Bush administration’s understanding of executive power — and a critic with a background in constitutional law, no less. But apart from his disavowal of waterboarding (an interrogation practice the Bush White House had already abandoned), almost the entire Bush-era wartime architecture has endured: rendition is still with us, the Guantánamo detention center is still open, drone strikes have escalated dramatically, and the Obama White House has claimed the right — and, in the case of Anwar al-Awlaki, followed through on it — to assassinate American citizens without trial.

Douthat goes on the note that Obama’s reversals have generated barely a peep from liberals and the Democratic Party.

For the record, we agree with Douthat that some of Obama’s original complaints were overdrawn, and we are glad that he has not followed through on all that he promised when he was running for president in 2008. At the same time, his use of executive privilege has gone far beyond anything Bush or any other president ever contemplated, especially in his decision to stop enforcing immigration laws.

Meanwhile, that Obama still receives support from so-called progressives indicates that both they and he have been engaged in breathtaking hypocrisy over the years. They never cared about the wars in Iraq or Afghanistan, or the people being killed there. They never cared about whether the president had received proper congressional authority to wage war. They never cared about rendition, torture, Guantanamo Bay, or the rights of suspected terrorists. They never cared about NSA spying or drone assassinations. They never cared about whether a president would lie to them, stonewall Congress, and claim executive privileged in order to avoid releasing documents showing illegality. They never cared about homosexual rights or gay marriage. They never cared about whether the president was forcing his religious views on others through his policies and executive actions. They never cared about budget shortfalls and government spending. They never cared about whether the president was observing Congress’s right of advice and consent. They never cared about whether the president was giving due respect for decisions handed down by the judiciary.

Yet, for eight solid years, these things were all they whined about, and even today they point fingers at Bush for these “crimes”, when they themselves are doubly guilty.

In the end, the only thing they cared about was getting their own man elected. They had no principles. Truth was not in them. It was and is all partisan politics. Loathsome, despicable, and dishonest, they dishonor the political discourse and their country.

Sadly, some on the right are little better. For example, Mitt Romney rejects some of what Obama has done, but mostly on grounds of policy and on the view that Obama and his team are inept. A consistent conservative position would be that many of Obama’s policies are not just wrong, but unconstitutional and illegal. Let’s be clear: Obama has a right to follow policies he sees fit, but he does not have a right to disobey the law and usurp the constitution. The proper conservative position should thus be disagreement on policy grounds, and outrage over the illegality. Romney is able to show some disagreement, but has no outrage and in fact seems largely oblivious to much of the illegality.

Does Romney really believe in limited executive or federal authority? If so, where does he draw the line?

At the same time, where do conservatives draw the line? While it is proper to acknowledge that Romney will be a better president than Obama and thus should be elected, is he to be given a free pass simply because he is our man? Are conservatives going to hold his feet to the fire on the basis of principle, or surrender to partisan hypocrisy just as the left has done?

This will be the true test of whether or not conservatism will survive the next four years.

Enhanced by Zemanta
About these ads
This entry was posted in politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Obama’s Executive Power Hypocrisy

  1. blained13 says:

    In the end many conservatives were turning a blind eye to what Bush was doing because he was their guy. The liberals and democrats are no different, so the question is are conservatives going to stand up even against their own. If Romney wins we must hold his feet to the fire, otherwise what’s the point of not standing up for the values of conservatism.

  2. Pingback: Before It's News

  3. Pingback: Romney Is Mr. Normal – John Malcolm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s